Here are some data on the acceptability, according to public opinion, of the use of torture. (A more descriptive post on torture is here).
Content
1. International public opinion
2. U.S. public opinion
3. Guantanamo
1. International public opinion
(source)
(source)
^ back to top
2. U.S. public opinion
(source)
(source)
^ back to top
3. Guantanamo
go torture!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That is horrible, how can you say that. Torture is completly unacceptable, and I bet that you would not like to be tortured.
viva tortura, I think we should torture everybody,
In your face Stacie
OH, you convinced me.
HAHAHAHAHA its so funny to hurt people
I’m pretty sure no one wants to be tortured, just like no one wants to go to prison when they commit a crime, but guess what…… that still happens. You are arguing that “You would not like a punishment if it happened to you.” That’s just stupid.
Your common sense is a foreign concept to Stacie…
i think all huggy heads should be tortured if captured……. we should cut their fingers off inch by inch
I agree!
:)
The ignorance of those statements is appalling! Have you ever looked at the amount of good or usable information is gained by torture? Have you ever considered the number of enemies you make as a result of choosing to torture? I assure you the statistics on that information would TOTALLY contradict the comments of those from bj and Janie. Surely these are from children and not ADULTS.
Thank You for clearing that up. People can truly be ignorant sometimes. Torture is an easy thing to say but the effects of it are every harsh. The Psychological pain as well as the physical pain are extremely severe. Torture is not a good source to turn to. People in pain will say anything to stop the pain. Not only that, torture degrades our morality and brings us to the level of a terrorist. Our right to call ourselves descent human beings depends on our part being one.
aj. first of all, you are ridiculous. obviously these people don’t believe what they’re saying. you’re ignorant for thinking that they are serious. second off, all the “statistics” that you are referring to are NEVER a true reflection of what is actually going on. Its disappointing how ignorant YOU are.
Seriously! You’re all so ignorant that it hurts! Don’t you realize that despicable acts such as torture cause mental disorders such as PTSD? People who experience torture are scarred and most likely can’t live a normal life. Plus, the ones sent to carry out the horrible act are affected as well. They become steadily more agressive and short tempered to those around them. Think before you take a barbaric side on this issue. I’m only 16 but my research paper on this issue states that I know what I’m talking about.
You all are completely missing the point: If you had a terrorist, and this terrorist had planted multiple bombs set to detonate in 5 minutes, and these explosives were placed all around your local metropolis, and the only way to get the location of these explosives out of this terrorist was to torture him, you all wouldn’t do it? Kill or disable one to save millions? I really could care less if a Islamic radical suffers from PTSD after we torture him. He made the decision to become a terrorist, to blow up schools full of innocent children, to even sink as low as recruiting the mentally retarded for suicide missions. Yes, I agree that the statistics would contradict my sentiments, but you must keep in mind that an overwhelmingly large percentage of people will believe in the stats and any other type of political refuse that organizations like the ACLU and Amnesty International will feed them. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if these statistics were issued by such an organization given the confidentiality of the American Secret Service (Who, keep in mind, has been torturing for a long time and continues to today). We are a nation of rules fighting against a religion that has no rules. Kind of a dandy way to lose a war, wouldn’t you agree? Before you all get in a fuss about your precious documents like the Geneva Conventions, I must remind you: Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Jordan, and all of the other Middle Eastern breeding grounds for human garbage like terrorists, were NOT signatories of the Geneva Conventions, nor will they ever be. The bottom line is, the laws and Constitution of this country are great, but don’t delude yourself into thinking that Jefferson, Washington, Franklin, or any of our Founding Fathers created such beautiful documents so that we could use them to protect terrorists. Not torturing anyone sounds so wonderfully Utopian, it looks so good on paper, right? The reality is, it’s a great way to lose a war. They hate us because they hate us, and they will continue to hate us no matter the amount of leeway we give them or how hard we try to “understand” them. I respect your views, but you all are suggesting a foreign policy driven by ACLU-esque ideas. The day we start considering feelings of other countries or letting the ACLU or UN drive our foreign policy is the day we are truly screwed.
Your statement about signatories of the Geneva Convetion is wrong: http://www.icrc.org/ihl.nsf/WebSign?ReadForm&id=375&ps=P
And your “multiple bomb” case is obviously more “utopian” than the struggle against torture. Most if not all torture that takes place today, in the US and elsewhere, is not of the ticking bomb type you and others regularly cite as a justification of torture.
Filip. you are a classic hypersensitive fag
no one has read this whole comment. EVER
Torture is never, ever, EVER justified. Not to save lives. Not to win a war. Period. I can not even IMAGINE conditions under which I would consider torture justified. I would rather seen the entire human race wiped out rather than allow the torture of one person. It doesn’t matter who that person is. TORTURE IS WRONG. Period. There are NO exceptions. NONE.
Your right, since you wrote a paper about the subject, you must be an expert. Hail Courtney. PTSD is a sad side effect to a harsh means of getting information, but your inferring that a person who undergoes torture is an innocent little lamb who couldn’t defend itself and is a victim. Considering said torture is conducted by the US, the subjects of the torture are guaranteed to be under some pretty heft suspicion, i.e. they aren’t in that position by accident. Also, the US does not conduct any inhumane or brutal torture by any means. You choose, be nice because it makes you feel high and mighty, or do the right thing and get what needs to be done, with out excessive or outrageously cruel means, of course.
BOOM>roasted
And thank yous go out to AJ and Logos
Hello, I’m Danielle. These people slash off the heads of our Soldiers screaming Alalalala…[Not trying to be funny, I know this is a Statistic.], And you are also right. People come back with disorders like those that come back with Vietnam Syndrome. Examples: Crawling on thier bellies when they are in a gun shop.. But that has nothing to do with this. I’ll stop myself there. The only torture i see fit is holding thier heads under water, and telling them to tap thier hand on the ground when they are ready. Give them 5 minutes under the water. You don’t know if they trained. I find this helpful. I hope others do to. May I remind you I’m 14, And I’m already running a debate report on why torturing, in some ways, is right.
maybe this will be useful
Then again, I’m in middle school. Who cares what comes from a young girls head?
yeah no one cares what you think
hey, i care what she thinks.
everyone has HUMAN RIGHTS.
I do not believe that torture is right, although sometimes it is “justified”. i believe that one is able to use torture when innocent lives are in danger, but sometimes the information that the victim tells is false, either because they just want the torture to stop, or because they are INNOCENT.
i’m not saying that everyone who gets tortured is innocent, i just believe that there must be proof first.
then again, there ARE the long lasting effects on either end…
Hi together
Can anyone inform me about torture statistics for different countries….
thanx!
I mean vor example: how many torture victims live in Budapest, England, US..
I don’t think something like that exists. Torturers don’t keep public accounts.
Courtney you are an idiot. what are you doing? your just embarrassing yourself. never look up statistics of torture again! If they done something bad enough to be tortured they’re probably not exactly having a “normal” life.
Torture is neccessary. There is no probable way to get information from a terrorist. And who cares if a terrorist gets mental disorders.
i completely agree. terrorist are the scum of the earth. like nazi’s on steriods!
Those of you who say torture is not justified because of the psycological harm it does to those being tortured, wake up. The psycological damage done to the loved ones of the soldiers and civilians killed by terrorist acts is far more severe. A terrorist who needs therapy after being tortured to save lives is a much better scenario than a wife or family of someone who was killed in a suicide bombing that couldve been stopped with the information gained by torture.
Pingback: Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics (31): Common Problems in Opinion Polls « P.A.P. Blog – Human Rights Etc.
I’m studying to be a psychologist, so I kind of want to look at this from an objective, two-sided perspective.
1) Everyone does have human rights, and who are we, essentially equal to each other as human beings, to judge these rights and deprive other people of them. I think most people would agree that it’s not acceptable in any way, shape, or form to torture randomly, with no justifiable motive, or any more that serves some other purpose. I couldn’t walk down the road and decide to take you hostage and beat you because I felt like doing so on that particular day. Even in the context of trying to get answers out of somebody, regardless of the cause or the reason that such answers are being sought, do we really have a right to hold one person’s rights in higher esteem than another’s?
2) What about the cases when somebody, such as a terrorist, has the answer or information upon which everyone’s fate lies? Such as the location of dangerous bombs, etc. Do we not have the right to preserve the lives of ourselves and those of “sounder minds”(not to place full judgment–as that would be implying that those of certain faiths, such as Islam which in some terms supports Jihad and Holy Wars–are crazy. It is not my place to make that judgment)over that of the person who is putting our lives in jeopardy?
There’s something about your second point here: http://filipspagnoli.wordpress.com/2009/03/26/the-little-door-to-hell-torture-and-the-ticking-bomb-argument/
I have definitely considered the faultiness of the ticking time bomb argument. It is generally unrealistic, I agree. But I’m sure people would agree there are instances, of course much less dramatic than a 5 minute life-or-death situation, such as the TBA suggests, that occur over a slightly longer time line that still are a life-or-death matter and would necessitate torture.
Anyone hear of the Milgram experiment? An ordinary college student was forced to “torture” someone by sending them death voltage shocks through wires attched to the victim. In reality,the victim was only pretending to be shocked, but the student didn’t know this and truly believed he was torturing the victim. Do you know how many students were turned into sadists or pyschologically damamged after the experiment? Torture not only hurts the victims but also the U.S. military down in Guantanamo being forced to torture.
And of course, goes the saying, “an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind”
-Ghandi
not if you leave one eye
Pingback: Measuring Human Rights (12): Measuring Public Opinion on Torture | P.a.p.-Blog, Human Rights Etc.
ok, torture rocks, and if you have a problem with it, go die you fucking democrats!
“torture rocks”?? I’m embarrassed to admit that I apparently am affiliated with the same party as you. If you don’t have anything substantiated to say, I don’t understand why you waste our time posting on this website. There are two fundamental questions regarding torture: Does it work? & secondarily, if it does work, is it moral in certain circumstances? I believe that the answer to second question isn’t pertinent because the answer to the first is no. If you do some research, I believe that you will find the same answer to this question. Also, in response to everyone’s accusations of the “terrorists” we are torturing, some of these “terrorists” are children, many of them were just supplied to us by bounty hunters for inordinate sums of money, and our government very rarely has enough evidence to convict any of these so-called “terrorists”.
I’m not sure who you are and where you come from but there is NEVER a good reason to torture someone.
1) ticking time bomb scenario is rare
2) if your torturing a terrorist, he’s gonna think your a butthole and tell you random information so you get off his nut and to get revenge for torturing him in the first place
3) people are stupid and get all worked up and think too much about a perfectly logical answer.
4) do your research. it might help.
I’m seeing a lot of comments of here whining “YOU SHOULD NEVER TORTURE!” Sure, you shouldn’t jump to torturing right away, but it’s not like giving them a free place to stay and enough meals will convince them to say anything. Plus, not all torture is “Drag a machete across their back” or “water boarding.” There is nothing “inhumane” about annoying the shit out of a terrorist by blasting loud horrible music and keeping them up all night or smacking them around a little. And please, don’t go for the argument “If you’re just gonna torture them, then why not kill them?” That’s easy. Because doing that is “INHUMANE!”
ive been rescearching this topic for a debate. im affermitive. i agree u should torture terrorists because sometimes it truely is a life or death situation and torture isnt allways death in fact in all cases death is a stupid thing to do because its killing your source of information. im twelve but allot smarter then some of you who just cry saying ohh but there people too, yeah people who just KILLED some one you may know. maybe its ur neighbor or ur brother maybe its ur mom who cares just suck it up people in third world countries have it allot worse then these terrorists and most are just small girls!
Some of the comment you guys have made are truly ignorant. Those of you that naively think that the use of torture will magically save your country from all potential terrorists and treats are seriously deluded. Most of you don’t even begin to understand the effect torture has on the person inflicting the pain as well as the receiver. This isn’t some glorified interrogation technique that gets the right answers every time or is the solution to terrorism. Your explanations to why it is acceptable are ridiculous – this is TORTURE – an act whereby you are not only inflicting psychological and/or physical pain on someone that will be guaranteed to have problems for the rest of their life (if they even live through it), but you are also condoning that someone should actually accept doing that do another human being. There are so many problems facing torture that I cannot understand how any of you could truly allow it. Torture ruins people’s lives and very rarely has a positive outcome. I cannot comprehend how some of you honestly think that the use of torture and therefore a “guaranteed” way of getting information from hostile threats will automatically save billions of lives… wake up, most recipients would say anything to make the torture stop, in most cases the information is gained too late, or worst case scenario, the victim is actually innocent (but the torture doesn’t stop because the interrogators don’t believe them). I’m ashamed to see that this is what this generation trusts to be our salvation – have we not come further than that believed in the Middle Ages? Torture isn’t the right answer and is nowhere near a solution to terrorism. But continued, all that will be left is a world that is seriously messed up in justifying a technique that is ultimately inhuman and perverse.
I too am doing a research on torture of terrorist. I am pro. Some information that was gathered from torture helped kill Osama Bin Laden. OBL was a huge threat to the United States Of America, well because of torture techneques, he is now fish food. I do not agree with killing people with torture though, they should live out their life in a cell for what they have done, enemies of the U.S. knew who they were dealing with in the beginging. we should not let them off with a slap on the hand.
I agree with torture and i’m doing a exam for it, the point is…the situation in which an innocent person is tortured is more unlikely than what you think is the ticking time bomb situation, they dont just start torturing any one wearing a scarf! And all your points against torture are just you saying its ‘inhumane’ inhumane? seriously? if a dog kills a cat you call it natural and dogs have there own mind to decide, its natural to kill, but torture ain’t killing so those terrorists should be glad they’re not dead! Any way who decides wether its inhumane, to me inhumane is just a sad excuse for judging.
Not just anyone is tortured who comes off the street you know, most likely the person being tortured is already so messed up that that is the only thing that solves the problem which involves the lives of innocent people.
I’m against harsh torture, but things like short term waterboarding or even isolation cells are okay to me. ( Against terrorists only) Waterboarding causes no long term physical effects if done right, and may cause nightmares. But would you rather have one terrorist having nightmares, or thousands of people crying themselves to sleep over loses of loved ones that could have been prevented?
I am doing an argumentative essay on torture and I am pro. The excuses many people offer for why we shouldn’t torture are so lame. “The terrorist is just going to hate you for torturing him so he’s not going to tell you anything.” That is so stupid. Then people go and say “They’ll just say whatever to make the pain stop.” Yeah, because our intelligence agencies are so gullible, they’ll just believe ANYTHING a TERRORIST says. Our agencies aren’t stupid. They frame interrogations specifically for detecting falsehoods. They can tell when a terrorist isn’ telling the truth.
Nobody here can come up with a realistic scenario where torture is justified.
The best people have given so far is the ticking time bomb. Unfortunately, it is so flawed that I’m surprised it’s considered at all. It assumes that you know for sure the person is a terrorist, that you know for sure that the latter planted a bomb (funny, you’d think the only way to know that is through witness or camera, thus knowing where the bomb is anyway, and being able to evacuate), that only the terrorist knows how to disarm it, that torture is the only way to get it out of him.
I’ll be generous, and grant you all of these mistakes for the sake of it. Let me ask you people a question: the terrorist knows that he is probably doomed either way… so what makes you think you won’t instead get a wrong code which detonates the bomb prematurely… time during which you might have evacuated a place… whose fault is it then? Here’s another one: if you think the terrorist won’t break in time, would you torture his innocent relatives or friends in front of him, in the hopes that he’ll divulge info? Also, what counts as “saving lives”? If a terrorist rats out his buddies, have you saved lives? What if they retired from that kind of life and planned to never kill or main again?
Welcome to reality, kiddies. Here, we most often “suspect” people of being terrorists, and we “hope” that we have a way to fix the situation… that’s if we even know what fixing the situation means. Uncertainty is a daily event. These extreme scenarios you people come up with, where torture is the “only” way out, are full of holes and/or quasi-impossible.
Jack, I think you are misunderstanding our points. Terrorist are not tortured to get a code that will “disarm” a bomb. Do you know how stupid that would be? They would give us the wrong code. We have experts that can disarm bombs. Torture is used on members of terrorist organizations to get information about planned attacks and targets. And yes, many terrorists plan to die; however, they are human. And there is only so much “pain” a human can take before breaking. If some pain will spare future American lives what’s the problem?
Even now, I’m still not sure exactly where I stand, but I do know that people would be talking out the other side of their mouths if it was their family that was killed in a terrorist attack. I do not agree with the absolutely “sickly disturbing” treatment of prisoners that has gone on in the past., but that’s not what I’m talking about. I’m talking about times when it is necessary.
I don’t understand how anyone could want to have another human being hurt like that. I think it provides people with a false sense of security, which is stupid. I understand we want information, but just let the CIA handle all that. The fact that we make a huge fuss over POWs being tortured and then still torture terrorists makes us international jerks.
And waterboarding IS torture. Honestly, if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it’s a quacking duck!
I am a college student in Saint Louis and am doing a research paper on how the current generation views torture vs. how they view torture from medieval times I am considering these times to be 12th-18th century although not completely accurate. If torture is used should it be used totally, for crimes like rape, theft, murder, etc? or from what I have read here just for terrorists? If we use it to “get information” why would it not be useful in other crimes? Would it serve as a deterrent? I have not made a judgment either way but have been looking through blogs and post for weeks like this for weeks and would like some direct feedback to these questions and some possible links to personal on known of blogs…. Please and thank you!
Try this: http://atheism.about.com/od/christianityviolence/ig/Christian-Persecution-Witches/Sexual-Torture-Witches.htm and this: http://atheism.about.com/od/christianityviolence/a/witches_3.htm